Is Television Viewing harmful to children? This question has been asked many times in the past and the most frequent answer is yes. Many people feel as though television has no positive effects on children and that children should not watch television at all. Violence on television, inappropriate behaviors, and how they negatively affect children has been an ongoing debate for a very long time, which is why I chose to touch on this topic.
Pediatricians recommend that children younger than 2 years old should not watch television at all, meanwhile three-quarters of American children currently live in homes where a television is on most of the time. Previous research has concluded that babies and toddlers who watch television for long periods of time have a significantly higher risk for developing Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) by the time they are 7 years old.Heavy television viewing throughout childhood has also been shown to contribute to behavioral and sleep problems. Children usually imitate what they see, so if a character on television is behaving violently or aggressively, the child is more likely to behave in the same manner.
Those who believe that television is harmful for children fail to look at the positive effects that it actually does have on our youth. Television is a significant influence in the socialization of children, and it can be filtered through a variety of sociological mechanisms such as the family. Children's viewing preferences are influenced by what they perceive their parents would want them to watch, and parents who emphasize family relations and the interpersonal nature of those relations are the ones in control of their children's viewing behaviors. Television itself is not to blame, but rather the parents who allows their children to watch certain programs and do not look after their children. Yes, parents may not always be around to monitor their child's every move, however, that is where values instilled in children by parents come into play. To me, it is like being able to determine right from wrong, and as children, it is quite easy to distinguishh between the two.
Educational programs such as Sesame Street as well as many others, allow frequent viewers to obtain higher grades in Math, English, and Science as opposed to children who do not watch the programs. Children's television programs enhance self-esteem and their understanding of others' feelings and behaviors. Mister Roger's neighborhood was the primary, best-designed program that aimed at addressing the social and emotional development of young children. In experimental studies with pre-school children, this television show enabled them to increase thier pro-social behaviors which included sharing, helping, and cooperating with others.
According to kidshealth.org, coming up with a family TV schedule, watching television with children, and talking to them about what they see on TV are practical ways to make screen time more productive. For instance, if something that you do not approve of appears on the tv screen, take time out to ask the child thought provoking questions such as "Do you think it was ok when those two mean got into a fight?." Television can be used to explain situations and express feelings toward difficult situations such as sex, love, drugs, etc. Adults can teach their children to question and LEARN from what they see on tv. Therefore television is beneficial, not harmful, and since television is here to stay, parents must view it as a resource and not necessarily a menace.
The Nonsense on TV...
Response By: Jazmon Kearse
As a child I was taught at the young age to know the difference between real and fake. My mother made sure we comprehended that you couldn't imitate what you always saw on television. I mean honestly I believe that if you educate your children first whatever appears on the television will not reflect their way of thinking. However, with me being a parent now I have taken on a new approach.
When I was growing up there were lots of cartoons and educational shows, but now they all seem to have either been cancelled or only play for a short amount of time. For instance while I was home with my son I would try to find some television shows that he could look at and/or hear that would soothe him, but I seemed to only find these ridiculous cartoons. For instance I liked the Backyardigans but was skeptical about it when I learned that the two characters that are supposed to represent the African Americans are named Uniqueqa (Not sure if the spelling is right…but you get the idea) and Tyrone. I mean seriously? Were there not any other names available? There’s also this show called Max and Ruby. Now these two little rabbits live all by themselves with not a parent insight. And the entire episode consists of Max doing what he’s told not to do repeatedly and Ruby telling him he’s wrong. All this teaches is obedience, there’s no educational aspect of it at all! Then I noticed that after 11am Nick Jr. ended and these brutal cartoons come on.
There’s Fairly Odd Parents where Timmy Turner is either getting beat up or creating some sort of chaos. And SpongeBob Square Pants where he always has some sort of ridiculous problem or is getting into spats with Squidwird. This represents once again another cartoon of no substance. Then when I turn to the Disney Channel there’s a group of “non-masculine” men singing and dancing around the screen. Now I have no problem with homosexuals, before anyone jumps to any conclusions, I am just saying can we not introduce children to this at the prime ages of six and under!
I mean where’s the shows like Gullah, Gullah Island, Allegra’s Window, and Rugrats where you learned life lessons and about using your imagination. I know that eventually my son will grow up and want to watch television but the question is if there’s violence in children’s shows now what will be in those of the future.
I hear what you are saying that if you sit and talk with a child about what you watch that you can prevent them from being affected by the media. But let’s be honest if a three year old child flips through the channels trying to get to Nickelodeon and sees a man and women partaking in sexual intercourse, how would you go about explaining that? I can’t say who is wrong or right on this topic but I will say that as a parent I know that I am very reserved about whether or not Kaden will be watching television as often as he wishes.
12 comments:
I agree with Shaunte's argument that television is not harmful to children. It is up to the parents to monitor what the child watches on television, and if they are not able to monitor their child's every move there are ways to block certain channels on your TV.
I have nephews and nieces who watch TV all the time and they learn things from the programs they watch, such as colors, numbers, emotions, etc.
Television is not harmful to children as long as they are watching programs apporpriate for their age range.
-Sasha Mills
Although there are some cases of educational television, there is no way a family can monitor what their child watches all the time. Too often there is a commercial that talks about sex, or an advertisement for something negative. Television ratings such as R or PG are getting less strict. On television programs on Disney there are more cases of teenage dramas and other issues brought up. Children as young as 2 may watch these programs. Too be sure that your child doesn't watch something you don't want them to, you have to be really strict with the t.v. which many parents don't have time for.
shanika simmons
MS. Francis, I enjoyed reading your blog. It was well organizaed, along with being clear and concise. By providing background information on the issue, it made your argument stronger. It was not difficult to see your stand onm the issue. You made reference to other sources, utilizing the voice of experts (kidshealth.org) also aided to your argument. Overall, your argument was well developed and structured.
By: Raavin R Evans
I agree, television CAN be good when it is a family-oriented activity.
Children sit in front of the television set all day and night because for a lot of kids the TV serves as a "babysitter." This is not the way to raise children. Children need dialogue. They may talk to the TV but the TV cannot actively talk back. Yes, some shows are enriching to a child's learning but nothing is better than when a parent becomes involved in teaching their children life and learning skills.
I was not raised on Sesame Street. My parents taught me everything I needed to know. When my parents could not be there, they appointed my older sister to teach me my ABC's--not Elmo. Now, there is nothing wrong with Elmo, but family plays a more pivotal role in child development. And I can honestly say my fondest childhood memories involve things that I did with my family, not what I watched on television.
I agree with the authors standpoint. I feel that television is not harmful unless you make it harmful. A parent has the ability to shape their childs initial interaction with the television. When I was younger my mother controlled what my sister and I watched and gave us timelines of when we were allowed to watch tv. We could not watch tv on school nights for a long time and could only view our favorite programs friday through sunday. Looking back I see this as beneficial because it kept me focused but at the same time didn't exclude me from the world of television.
-Ashley Calloway
Shaunte, I totally agree with your argument. It is the parent's responsibility to monitor what their children watch. There are many things on television that are not designed for children and then again there are TV channels that were created to cater to the needs of children at every age level. I know as a child, my parents, grandparents, and other family members made sure my cousins and I were wacthing educational and other TV programs that were befitting to our age. So, I feel that parents today need to take responsibility and do the same.
-Ashley R. Jones
I disagree that tv is harmful to children, but I do agree that some shows as well as commercials can be harmful to children. Ultimately it is the responsibility of the parent to monitor the child and what they are watching.
-CW
I feel that watching television can be very harmful to children. When a young child sees something, no matter how much a parent speaks to them about it, a child registers that. There are too many times, children act on what they see. Too many times my cousins and I played power rangers, stabbing eachother and kicking eachother. We were behaving violently. The fact is: you cannot monitor your child 24 hours a day when television is really accesible.
-Nia Newton
I don't believe watching televison in general is bad for children however there are shows that children should be protected from. It is up to the parents to teach their children wrong from right. Life will expose children to more harmful things than the televison will. This was a very good topic!
BriElla Nelson
Well I do agree with everything that you said here. I am one who does not want children for this very reason. I do not want to have to tell my children that they cannot watch a wholesome cartoon because I fear that they will see something negative just turning to their favorite station.T.V. does in fact have a negative affect on a child's development if we as older role models and parents allow them to watch and be subjected to that type of programming.
Sascha
Although I agree, I strongly think that it is still up to the parents. The media does have a strong impact but I am convinced that we all know this. So now that we all know, let take control. As parents, we must monitor what our kids watch. I think that what Prof. Greene is doing is a great idea. I will not be having a television in my house when i have kids either.
I think that television can be harmful to children. Although you say that you don't believe it is, you support the idea that it can potentially damaging because you encourage parents to monitor it. If it could not affect our children negatively, then you would have no problem allowing them to watch violent or sexually explicit content. I know that I will be strictly controlling what my children watch on television. However, I do recognize the educational capabilities of TV. It might be a good idea to encourage parents to use only DVD's of educational programs in order to limit the exposure to adult content on commercials and flipping from channel to channel.
Post a Comment